Baseball Toaster was unplugged on February 4, 2009.
toaster 'at" humbug.com
Am I a jinx or something? Just hours after I had written that the A's bench is not a bottomless pit, my statement gets tested. Mark Ellis is out 6-8 weeks after dislocating his shoulder in a collision with Bobby Crosby.
We'll soon find out how valuable Ellis' defense really is. If Hudson and Mulder start giving up a lot more hits than usual this April, we'll know why.
Although Frank Menechino is also hurt, the A's shouldn't miss much offensively. And this illustrates what I enjoy most about watching Billy Beane work. You can talk all you want about Hudson, Mulder, Zito and Chavez, but Beane's real genius shows up in the 35th-40th men on the roster. He creates depth at every position. When Ellis gets hurt, he not only has one competent backup, he has three (with Baseball Prospectus projections):
Name | OBP | SLG |
Mark Ellis | .325 | .378 |
Frank Menechino | .342 | .334 |
Marco Scutaro | .337 | .412 |
Esteban German | .326 | .347 |
Now compare those numbers to the projected numbers of the other middle infield backups in the AL West: | ||
Willie Bloomquist, Sea | .303 | .341 | Ramon Santiago, Sea | .317 | .339 | Chone Figgins, Ana | .311 | .363 | Adam Riggs, Ana | .299 | .380 | Alfredo Amezaga, Ana | .295 | .343 | Jason Bourgeois, Tex | .297 | .363 | Eric Young, Tex | .336 | .371 |
The entire division has only one middle infield backup, Eric Young, who is a better hitter than the A's fourth-string second baseman. That's why Billy Beane is so good. And that's why I said the A's can win a war of attrition.
I just wish I wasn't so right so soon.
Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.